Unionization mends the pitfalls of temporary employment that can bring a student or faculty member’s untenured progress to a halt.
Written and edited by Katya Incle, Allison Brown, and Jamie Dietrich, members of United Campus Workers of Arizona – CWA Local 7065
A response to Evan D. Morris, “Postdocs Aren’t Burger Flippers: Why Unionization Is a Bad Idea” in Inside Higher Ed.
We couldn’t help but wince at the unwieldy ideas about unionization in higher education in Evan D. Morris’ recent article. It seems he’s too far removed from postdoc needs to understand the purpose of union safeguards. Instead of questioning why he wrote this piece in the first place, we offer here insights he may have overlooked on the importance of unionization.
Morris begins by using Michelangelo to illustrate how a unionized (and thus, inherently lazy?) apprentice could have derailed the completion of the Sistine Chapel. This nonexistent apprentice would be to blame for the downfall of an artwork Michelangelo didn’t even want to do in the first place.
Michelangelo considered himself a sculptor, rather than a painter. He agreed to paint the Sistine Chapel only after political/religious and financial pressures reared their ugly heads. Rather than focusing on projects aligning with his passions, Michelangelo submitted to the whims of those signing the paychecks. Sound familiar? When mentors pressure postdoctoral mentees to commit to work inapplicable to their own goals, how can they say no? In isolation, mentors like this can leverage that power imbalance, exploiting the mentee’s lack of experience or other work opportunities.
With this in mind, consider the professional parameters of mentorship that mentors (or any bosses) are responsible for maintaining. Yet, to Morris, “…if you’re my postdoc and you declare that you won’t… help when I’m working over the weekend to support our shared glory, then don’t expect that invitation for Thanksgiving. I don’t invite the guy who charges me by the hour to cut my lawn. I invite my friends.” Here’s a loaded question: should postdocs work overtime as a free favor for a friend, or should they work overtime only as needed while being properly compensated? If you’re so worried about unions ruining the mentor-mentee relationship, you could foster better relationships with your mentees while paying them what they’re worth.
We know how we’d prefer to treat our friends.
Overtime is not a courtesy done out of kindness, or hoping for eventual, intangible rewards; it is labor that should be fairly compensated. Rather than committing to a shallow, transactional relationship with someone who would abandon you the moment you stand up for yourself, we implore postdocs to consider how unions have their backs without manipulative conditions. Unions aren’t taking away the ability of mentors to decide they don’t like someone personally; we’re just taking away their power to mistreat the mentee because of it.

Another questionable take from the article: “The value of a good postdoctoral fellowship is not to be measured in salary but in the opportunity to learn at the feet of, yes, a master.” Somehow ignoring the connotation of ‘master’, this statement remains deceptive. Most pursuing their passion are fueled by a love for their field rather than salary; however, Morris suggests their passionate labor does not deserve compensation.
So, only labor we don’t find fulfilling deserves compensation? I wonder if he’d consider the choices this leaves postdocs: abandon their passions to toil away in an unfulfilling job, or work for free in the forbidding capitalist system under which we reside (taking on more debt in the process). Why must those be the options? He continues, “If we allow unions to commoditize the work of postdocs…” We didn’t commoditize anything; the oppressive, capitalist society we currently exist under did. We’re just hungry.
Morris has a fundamental misunderstanding of what unions do, saying, “Unions are about treating everyone, every problem, and every circumstance exactly the same… What is passed from the mentor to the mentee is not something that can be codified or regulated—especially not by groups focused on hours of sick leave or retirement benefits.” This implies that paid time off and benefits shouldn’t matter, and that unions refuse to challenge their own internal structures, which is demonstrably untrue. Every worker deserves paid leave and someone on their side to fight for those benefits. Unions respond to needs workers have, building power to transform working conditions so that workers can not only live, but thrive.
Revisiting Michelangelo, it’s important to note the time and obstacles he faced completing the Sistine Chapel. Imagine how much more smoothly it could have gone with a union backing him up? His work was halted for over a year thanks to a dispute over, you guessed it (postdocs will), traveling to secure the pay he was promised. To no one’s surprise, Michelangelo also sustained debilitating pain and arthritis after nearly four years craning his neck upward, painting intricate nudes. If only a dedicated union could have advised him on pay disputes and ensured the contract included physical therapy.
Surely, Michelangelo could’ve had a much better time painting his magnum opus with union support. The Sistine Chapel would still exist, but with a much healthier outcome.

Michelangelo’s Malicious Compliance
Sources
- Blotto, C. (2025). How did Michelangelo paint the Sistine Chapel ceiling? Far Out Magazine. faroutmagazine.co.uk/how-was-sistine-chapel-ceiling-painted
- Graham-Dixon, A. (2009). Michelangelo and the Sistine Chapel (1st ed.). Skyhorse.
- IncleKat. (2026). Gay Sistine Chapel (user-generated). imgflip. imgflip.com/i/b0k49s
- IncleKat. (2026). Greedy Pipe Man (user-generated). imgflip. imgflip.com/i/b0k1ob
- Piccoli, B., Reisel, W. D., & De Witte, H. (2021). Understanding the Relationship Between Job Insecurity and Performance: Hindrance or Challenge Effect? Journal of Career Development, 48(2), 150–165. https://doi.org/10.1177/0894845319833189
