Worker-to-Worker Unionism in Higher Education

By Eric Blanc, assistant professor of labor studies at Rutgers University, member of Rutgers AAUP-AFT, and author of the substack Labor Politics.

It’s hard to overstate the stakes of rebuilding a powerful labor movement. When unions are weak, inequality soars, and workers lose their most important tool for challenging corporate power. Reversing this requires tens of millions more people to form and join unions.

The recent organizing surge among graduate student workers points toward a way forward. Its central lesson is simple: to build power at scale, unions must rely less on paid full-time organizers and more on workers organizing one another. Staff-intensive organizing can be extraordinarily effective, including at developing worker leaders. But it costs too much to spread widely.

Why We Need a New Model

Under current best practices, organizing campaigns often require at least one staffer for every hundred workers. Unionizing a single worker routinely costs more than $3,000, compared with roughly $88, adjusted for inflation, for each steelworker organized in the 1930s.

This poses an enormous obstacle to reviving labor. As I show in my latest book We Are the Union, even if unions spent an ambitious 30 percent of their liquid assets on staff-intensive campaigns, they could only recover their 2015 level of strength.

For decades, unions have recognized that successful campaigns require worker-led organizing committees. The challenge has been turning that principle into an approach capable of dramatically expanding organizing capacity.

Higher Education Shows What’s Possible

Since 2021, the United Electrical Workers (UE) has helped organize tens of thousands of graduate student workers. Its national membership more than doubled from 2022 to 2023. These campaigns operated with one staffer for between 1,609 and 4,100 workers—a far cry from the conventional one-to-100 ratio. UE supplied support and strategic guidance while worker leaders organized, trained, and persuaded their own coworkers.

As Valentina Luketa, an Indiana University organizing leader who later became a UE organizer, explains: “Nobody can hire enough staff to do that.” Scaling up labor’s fights, she argues, demands “a lot more workers organizing other workers.”

Universities do offer advantages: many graduate workers are young and progressive, and some face less repression than workers in other industries. But the campaigns have been anything but easy. Cornell graduate workers lost union elections in 2002 and 2017, before winning 1,873 to 80 in November 2023. The University of Chicago’s drive took fifteen years to prevail.

The Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) provides an especially revealing example. Beginning in 2019, graduate organizers faced an aggressive anti-union campaign. Administrators warned international students about potential visa problems and pressured professors to press their graduate employees against unionizing. Opponents even circulated fliers declaring, “A Vote for UE is a Vote for Putin.”

MIT’s predominantly STEM workforce, historically difficult to organize, made the challenge greater. So workers built an organizing committee of more than two hundred people, spanning departments and conducting systematic one-on-one conversations. They had developed their own training program even before affiliating with UE.

As worker leader Ki-Jana Carter explained, MIT’s workers chose to affiliate with UE because “UE’s democratic rank-and-file organizing model was very aligned with both what we wanted to see, what we were already beginning to do, and what kind of support we needed.”

Their campaign won, 1,785 to 912, on April 6, 2022. Ki-Jana remembered the emotional payoff: “We just all broke down in tears, nobody could stop cheering or hugging each other.”

Workers Training Workers

MIT’s victory helped launch the Graduate Worker Organizing Committee (GWOC), a national, digitally connected network through which graduate workers share organizing strategies and train one another. MIT leaders supported campaigns at Johns Hopkins, Northwestern, and Chicago. Those victories, in turn, helped build capacity for drives at Dartmouth, Minnesota, and Stanford.

GWOC developed with UE’s support as a way for workers who had just won their own battles to help guide other graduate workers, without turning each new drive into a staff-intensive campaign. The network uses digital tools to put national worker-to-worker guidance at the heart of its organizing, through both one-on-one mentoring and mass trainings. Instead of requiring full-time organizers to fly around the country to train each new campus, experienced worker organizers can share their lessons over Zoom. This makes it possible to connect and train organizers across dispersed universities cheaply and quickly.

It did not require campus groups to give up control over their own campaigns. Joining the national GWOC network, while maintaining their autonomy, was a major reason why Chicago’s organizers voted to join UE. As one graduate leader put it, “We were like, ‘Okay, tell us how to fish and then we’ll go and fish.’” In that sense GWOC offered something beyond advice from an outside organizer: workers who had already built a union could teach their counterparts elsewhere to build their own.

This multiplying effect is worker-to-worker unionism’s greatest promise: every victory can create new organizers capable of supporting the next campaign. Rather than depending on a constantly expanding professional staff, workers themselves become a growing reservoir of expertise.

GWOC has also begun addressing a major bottleneck: winning first contracts. Following their own 2023 agreement, MIT organizers shared lessons about open, mass-participation bargaining and building a credible strike threat. This challenges another costly labor movement convention—relying heavily on full-time bargaining representatives.

That shift is especially important because many newly unionized workers end up waiting for a limited number of experienced bargaining representatives to take on their contracts. GWOC instead connects them with peers who have just been through the same fight. Workers can learn from MIT’s fall 2023 victory how to conduct open, mass-participation negotiations and make a strike threat credible. This is more than sharing tips: it means making bargaining knowledge available across campuses, so that each contract victory expands the network’s ability to help win the next one.

The first-contract problem cannot be ignored. As one staff organizer told me, union representatives sometimes argue for slowing down new organizing because they lack capacity to negotiate agreements for workers who have already won recognition.

To overcome this constraint, labor needs far more worker-to-worker networks, accessible online bargaining trainings, open-source contract templates, and practical educational resources. In some cases, unions might also revive the 1930s practice of initially negotiating short, one-year recognition agreements, allowing worker committees more time to build the strength and knowledge needed for a subsequent contract fight.

A Strategy for Labor’s Revival

Graduate student organizing cannot simply be replicated everywhere. Workers differ in their confidence, ability to withstand retaliation, organizing experience, and willingness to take risks. More repressive employers present real obstacles, and unions still need paid staff and substantial resources.

But these differences are reasons to adapt the model, not to abandon it. Worker-to-worker organizing grows out of the best rank-and-file traditions of American labor. What is new is its demonstrated potential to organize at a scale that staff-heavy approaches cannot match.

As UAW president Shawn Fain puts it: “We don’t win by telling workers what to do, what to say, or how to say it. We win by giving working-class people the tools, the inspiration, and the courage to stand up for themselves.”

Rebuilding labor will require making that principle central to how unions organize—and how they win. Without a model capable of dramatic growth, unions cannot effectively confront inequality, authoritarianism, or the power of corporate America.